French social security system: the French revolution - the second half of the 20th century | Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta – Tomsk State University Journal. 2014. № 380. DOI: 10.17223/15617793/380/18

French social security system: the French revolution - the second half of the 20th century

This article presents a general historical and philosophical overview of the French social policy in 1789-1945 and aims to examine its main principles and the way how French philosophy contributed to the emergence of the "welfare state", a social concept consolidated in continental Europe. The study appeals to a range of philosophical and political theories of the French Revolution, the Industrial Revolution, and the before and aftermath of World War II. It starts with a brief analysis of main works of Ch.-L. Montesquieu and J.-J. Rousseau who were the first authors to point out the political organization of a relationship between the state and its citizens, and legal rights to social security resulting from it. The French Revolution being a symbol of widespread popular discontent brings reforms and new philosophical ideas to the eighteenth-century society in the field of social aid: socialist, egalitarian and communist theories. It created a new concept of social security based on common law and rules of social solidarity and justice opposed to the nineteenth-century economic liberalism. The modern French social security system takes its roots in the 1945 Program of the National Council of the Resistance aimed to consolidate achievements in the field of social security and to repair the economy from the war damage. The Decree serves as a guarantee of social sustenance and dignified pension wage in the case of impossible self-sufficiency. At the same time two types of "welfare state" - Bismarckian and Beveridgian - spread over the continental Europe that influenced further development of the French social system. The German model presumed a number of social guaranties related to employment status, compulsory social contributions of workers, opening of social security and state aid funds adopted by France afterwards. The 1945 social Program was then developed by Pierre Laroque, member of the Cabinet Minister for Work and Social Care, "father" of today's French social security system. The system adopts a number of features of German "welfare state", but then becomes autonomous and specific. Its main provisions are: corporate risk insurance split in four branches: workplace accident, pensions, illness benefits, family benefits; income redistribution; financial autonomy of social security funds; social financing resulting from employers' and employees' membership fees; opening of a universal fund of social protection, notwithstanding the split in several social payment schemes: entrepreneurs, SME owners, "special regimes" for farmers, agriculture workers, artisans, sailors, state officials, miners, railway workers, etc. Today the French social security system, as it was conceded after World War II, undergoes multiple structural crises of solvency, efficiency, legitimacy, especially, in the field of pensions and family benefits. Nevertheless, the French "welfare state" concept remains adaptive to the globalization process and evolving according to the French and international economic and political development cycles.

Download file
Counter downloads: 180

Keywords

principle of social solidarity, universalism, egalitarianism, theory of social rights, "welfare state", French system of social security, эгалитаризм, универсализм, право социального обеспечения, принцип социальной справедливости, «государство всеобщего благосостояния», французская система социального обеспечения

Authors

NameOrganizationE-mail
Firsova Yulia A.Tomsk State Universitydlarisa@inbox.ru
Всего: 1

References

Avenir de l'Union economique et monetaire : les pistes proposees par la Commission pour approfondir l'integration sociale // Site de la Commission europeenne. 2 octobre 2013. URL: www.europa.eu/rapid/press-release_IP_13_893_fr.htm (access date: 3.10.2013).
Jean Pisani-Ferry: «Notre modele social n'est pas efficace» // France Info. 17 octobre 2013. URL: www.franceinfo.fr/economie/un-monde-d-idees/ jean-pisani-ferry-notre-modele-social-n-est-pas-efficace-1179781-2013-10-17 (access date: 15.11.2013).
Penaud P., Amghar Y.-G., Bourdais J.-F. et al. Politiques sociales. 2e ed, presses de Sciences Po, Amphi-Dalloz, 2013.
Мартин Э. Социальное обеспечение в Великобритании и Франции // Полит.ру. 23 августа 2005. URL: http://polit.ru/article/2005/08/23/martin/ (access date: 10.08.2013).
Barbier J.-C., Theret B. Le systeme franjais de protection sociale. La Decouverte, Reperes, Paris, 2eme edition, 2009.
L'Etat-providence // La Vie Publique - Direction de l'Information legale et administrative, 30 mai 2006. URL: http://www.vie-publique.fr/decouverteinstitutions/finances-publiques/approfondissements/etat-providence.html (access date: 15.08.2013).
Le programme du CNR publie en 1944 // Fondation de la Resistance. URL: http://www.fondationresistance.org/documents/dossier_them/Doc00104. pdf (access date: 13.08.2013).
Historique du systeme franjais de Securite sociale // Le portail du service public de la Securite sociale, 12 avril 2013. URL: http://www.securite-sociale. fr/Historique-du-systeme-francais-de-Securite-sociale?type=part (access date: 9.08.2013).
Radbruch G. Rechtsphilosophie, 1878-1949, 3., ganz veu bearb. und stark verm. Aufl. Leipzig : Quelle & Meyer, 1932.
Imbert J. Guide du chercheur en histoire de la protection sociale (1789-1914). Vol. II. Paris : Association pour l'etude de l'histoire de la securite sociale, 1997.
Larofe R. La juridicisation des problemes sociaux : la construction juridique de la protection sociale // Informations sociales. 2010. № 157.
Paoletti G. Durkheim et la philosophie : representation, realite et lien social. Paris : Classiques Garnier, 2012.
Gaxie L. Du «droit individualiste» au «droit social». une histoire de la juridicisation du social (1789-1936) // Raison publique, 19 mars 2012. URL: http:// www.raison-publique.fr/article496.html (access date: 12.12.2013).
Gueslin A. Le paternalisme revisite en Europe occidentale (seconde moitie du XIX siecle, debut XX siecle). Geneses. 1992. Vol. 7. Issue 7.
Laurent A. et Valentin V. Les penseurs liberaux. Les Belles Lettres, Collection Bibliotheque classique de la liberte. 2012. Vol. 21.
Imbert J. Les droits de l'Homme en France. Paris, 1985.
Constitution du 24 juin 2013 // Conseil constitutionnel. URL: www.conseil-constitutionnel.fr/conseil-constitutionnel/francais/la-constitution/les-constitutions-de-la-france/constitution-du-24-juin-1793.5084.html (access date: 12.10.2013).
Dumas G. Autour de Babeuf // Annales historiques de la Revolution franjaise. 1977. Vol. 49.
Higonnet P. L.-R. Babeuf: Communist or Proto-Communist? // The Journal of Modern History. December, 1979. Vol. 51, № 4.
Goetz Ch. Plume de Marat : pour une bibliographie generale. Chantiers Marat. 2006. Vol. 9-10.
Labica G. Robespierre : une politique de la philosophie. 1ere ed., Philosophies. 1990. Vol. 30.
Terrel J. Les theories du pacte social: droit naturel, souverainete et contrat de Bodin a Rousseau. Points. 2001. Vol. 450.
Imbert J. La protection sociale sous la Revolution franjaise. Paris : Association pour l'etude de l'histoire de la Securite sociale, 1990.
Versini L. etMontesquieu Ch. de Secondat, baron de, De l'esprit des lois. Collection Folio/essais. 1995. Vol. 1. P. 275-276.
 French social security system: the French revolution - the second half of the 20th century | Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta – Tomsk State University Journal. 2014. № 380. DOI: 10.17223/15617793/380/18

French social security system: the French revolution - the second half of the 20th century | Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta – Tomsk State University Journal. 2014. № 380. DOI: 10.17223/15617793/380/18

Download full-text version
Counter downloads: 3151