Historiography of Dutch peacekeeping in national and foreign research | Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta – Tomsk State University Journal. 2015. № 398.

Historiography of Dutch peacekeeping in national and foreign research

The definition of "Dutch peacekeeping" or "Dutch peacekeepers" occurs very rarely in the Russian literature. It is first of all associated with the events in Bosnia-Herzegovina in July, 1995, when the Dutchbat could not prevent the tragedy and mass people killings, which will later be called the fall of Srebrenica. In the given article the author tries to follow the development of Dutch peacekeeping as a historical process in international relations based on the foreign and Russian scholars' works. The analysis of the Dutch foreign policy plays a significant role in considering the issue. The papers of Dutch researchers represent the major part in foreign historiography. The Dutch policy think tanks asserted a main influence to study the above-mentioned question. Among them are the NIOD Institute for War, Holocaust and Genocide Studies, the Netherlands Institute of International Relations Clingendael, as well as the Advisory Council on International Affairs (AIV) created in 1979. The latter consults the Dutch Government and Parliament on the issues of foreign policy, human rights, peace and security, cooperation in the field of development and European integration. One of the most significant works is a research which the NIOD Institute for War, Holocaust and Genocide Studies prepared in 1996-2002 at the request of the Dutch government after many countries, e.g., France and Canada, refused to take part in investigating the causes of the Srebrenica tragedy in 1995. In 2002, the scholars of the Institute published a report "Srebrenica - A 'safe' area. Reconstruction, background, consequences and analyses of the fall of a Safe Area". In Russian historiography the Dutch peacekeeping can be examined as an object only as part of the Dutch foreign policy works and conduct of the Kingdom of the Netherlands in the international arena as a small country. At present, the study of Dutch peacekeeping is an exclusive prerogative for foreign researchers and think tanks, in the first place, it concerns the Dutch ones. If until mid-1990s peacekeeping was examined as a historical process in international relations, since 1995 and in the 2000s the authors implemented new methods: gender studies, anthropology, psychological analysis; they also used the results of medical investigations. Dutch public opinion, relations between the executive and the legislative powers, influence of internal political factors on the decision-making process of how and when to deploy military forces in peacekeeping operations are considered. To sum up, research of Dutch peacekeeping by foreign authors covers many aspects, while there are only a few Russian papers: Soviet and, later, Russian scholars consider the issue of the Dutch participation in peacekeeping operations barely in the context of studying the history and foreign policy of the Kingdom of the Netherlands.

Download file
Counter downloads: 233

Keywords

Srebrenica, Dutch peacekeeping, Netherlands, миротворческие операции, Сребреница, голландское миротворчество, Нидерланды

Authors

NameOrganizationE-mail
Smolenchuk Olga Yu.Tomsk State Universitysmolenchuk@gmail.com
Всего: 1

References

Надин К. Внешняя политика Голландии. М., 1963.
Шатохина-Мордвинцева Г.А. История Нидерландов. М., 2007.
Бусыгин А.В. Побеждающие море: о Голландии и голландцах. М., 1990.
Тамарин Н.И. Современная Голландия. М., 1966.
Брандт Д.М. Нидерланды. М., 1953.
Островская Е.П. Нидерланды: большие проблемы малой страны. М., 1986.
Вальков В.А. Экономика и политика Голландии после Второй мировой войны. М., 1961.
Панкова Л.Н. Основные направления внешней политики Нидерландов в 70-е годы : дис.. канд. ист. наук. М., 1983.
Зайцева Н.И. Основные направления внешнеполитического курса стран Бенилюкс // Военная и внешняя политика западноевропейских государств. М., 1986. Ч. 2. С. 227-254.
Панкова Л.Н. Основные направления внешней политики Нидерландов в 70-е годы : автореф. дис.. канд. ист. наук. М., 1983.
Sollie H. Civiele Politie Op Vredesmissie: Uitzendervaringen Van Nederlandse Politiefunctionarisse. Apeldoorn: Politie & Wetenschap, 2010.
Шатохина-Мордвинцева Г.А. Нидерланды // Малые страны Европы в XX веке : учеб. пособие / отв. ред. О.А. Хорошева. 2-е изд. М. : Книжный дом «ЛИБРОКОМ», 2013.
van Schooten H., Werner W.G. Democratic control on the use of force under the Dutch constitution' // Tilburg Foreign Law Review. 2002. Vol.10, No 1. P. 43-62.
The Dutch participation in UN Peacekeeping operations // International Peacekeeping. December, 1994-January, 1995. P. 7-8.
de Graaff B. Activist and catalyst: Dutch moralistic decision-making regarding (former) Yugoslavia, 1991-1994 // Journal of European Integration History. 2002. Vol. 10, No 1. P. 139-168.
van Schendelen M.P. C.M. Information and Decision Making in the Dutch Parliament // Legislative Studies Quarterly. 1976. Vol. 1, No 2. P. 231250.
Andeweg R.B. The Dutch prime minister: Not yet chairman, not yet chief? // West Politics. 1991. Vol. 14, No 3. P. 116-132.
Kristic A. De Staten-Generaal en de inzet van de Nederlandse krijgsmacht: een onderzoek naar de parlementaire betrokkenheid bij de besluitvorming over deelname aan international militaire operaties. Kluwer, 2012. URL: https://pure.uvt.nl/portal/nl/publications/de-statengeneraal-en-de-inzet-van-de-nederlandse-krijgsmacht%28bce753b0-3e8f-4185-972b-119c0387055a%29.html, free
van der Meulen J., de Konink M. Risky Missions: Dutch Public Opinion on peacekeeping in the Balkans / Philip Everts, Pierangelo Isernia. Public Opinion and the International Use of Force. Routledge, 2003.
AnkersmitF. Het drama Srebrenica. Geschiedtheoretische beschouwingen over het NIOD-rapport. Redactie: Frank Ankersmit, Maria Grever, Ed Jonker, Rik Peters, Kees Ribbens. Assen, 2003.
Dekker I.F. Illegality and legitimacy of humanitarian intervention: Synopsis of and comments on a Dutch report // Journal of Conflict and Security Law. 2001. Vol. 6, No 1. P. 115-126.
Delpha I., BougaretX., Fournel J.-L. Investigating Srebrenica - Institutions, Facts, Responsibilities. N.Y. : Berghahn Books, 2012.
Houben M. No Blank Cheque: How and why European States Precondition Their Participation in International Crisis Management Operations. Leiden, 2003.
Hoekema J. Srebrenica, Dutchbat and the role of the Netherlands' parliament in Born H., Hanggi H. (eds.) // The «double democratic deficit»: Parliamentary accountability and the useof force under international auspices. Aldershot : Ashgate, 2004.
Cohen B.C. Democracies and Foreign Policy: Public Participation in the United States and the Netherlands. Madison : University of Wisconsin Press, 1995.
Cockburn C., Zarkov D. The postwar moment: Militaries, masculinities and international peacekeeping: Bosnia and the Netherlands. London: Lawrence & Wishart, 2002.
Bramsen I., Dirkzwager A.J. E., van Esch S.C.M., van der Ploeg H.M. Consistency of Self-Reports of Traumatic Events in a Population of Dutch Peacekeepers: Reason for Optimism? // Journal of Traumatic Stress. 2001. Vol. 14, No. 4. P. 733-740.
Joanne Mouthaan, Martin C. Euwema & Jos M.P. Weerts (2005): Band of Brothers in U.N. Peacekeeping: Social Bonding Among Dutch Peacekeeping Veterans, Military Psychology, 17:2, P. 101-114.
Sion L. Changing from Green to Blue Beret: A Tale of Two Dutch Peacekeeping Units. Amsterdam: Vrije Universiteit van Amsterdam, 2004.
Sion L. Reinterpreting Combat Masculinity: Dutch peacekeeping in Bosnia and Kosovo // Sociologie, the Netherlands. 2007. Vol. 3, No 1. P. 95 111.
Sion L. Dutch Peacekeepers and Host Environments in the Balkans: An Ethnographic Perspective // International Peacekeeping. 2008. Vol. 15, No 2. P. 201-213.
Sion L. Peacekeeping and the Gender Regime Dutch Female Peacekeepers in Bosnia and Kosovo // Journal of Contemporary Ethnography. 2008. Vol. 37, No 5. P. 561-585.
Bosman F., Joseph Soeters J., Ait Bari F. Dutch Muslim Soldiers During Peace Operations in Muslim Societies // International Peacekeeping. 2008. Vol. 15, No 5. P. 695-705.
Both N. From indifference to entrapment: the Netherlands and the Yugoslav crisis, 1990-1995. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press, 2000.
Karremans Th. Srebrenica, who cares?: Een puzzel van de werkelijkheid (in Dutch). Arko, 1998.
Park Il-Song, Yang Yong-Jo, Son Kyo-Suk. A History of Netherlands Forces' Participation in the Korean War. Ministry of Patriots & Veterans Affairs, The Republic of Korea. Seoul, 2010.
Bais K. Het mijnenveld van een vredesmacht: Nederlandse blauwhelmen in Cambodja. Den Haag : SDU Uitgeverij Koninginnengracht, 1994.
SchoenmakerB. The debate on the Netherlands contribution to UNIFIL, 1979-85 // International Peacekeeping. 2006. Vol. 12, No 4. P. 586-598.
Klep C., Winslow D. Learning lessons the hard way - Somalia and Srebrenica compared // Small Wars & Insurgencies. 1999. Vol. 10, No 2. P. 93-137.
Noll J.E. Leadership and Institutional Reform in Consensual Democracies. Dutch and Swedish Defense Organizations after the Cold War. Leiden, 2005. URL: https://openaccess.leidenuniv.nl/bitstream/handle/1887/2306/Thesis_Noll.pdf?sequence=3, free.
Klep C. Somalie, Rwanda, Srebrenica. De nasleep van drie ontspoorde vredesmissies. Amsterdam, 2008.
ten Cate A. De laatste divisie: de gescheidenisvan 1 Divisie '7 December' na de val de Muur 1989-2004. Den Haag : Sdu Uitgevers, 2004.
Klep C., van GilsR. Van Korea tot Kosovo: De Nederlandse militaire deelname aan vredesoperaties sinds 1945. Den Haag : Sduuitgevers, 1999.
Klep C., RoozenbeekH. Vredesmacht in Libanon : de Nederlandse deelname aan UNIFIL 1979-1985. Amsterdam : Boom, 2004.
ElandsM. Nederlandse militairen in Angola: de VN-vredesmissie UNAVEM II, 1991-1993. Den Haag, 1994.
ten Cate A. Waarnemers op heilige grond : Nederlandse officieren bij UNTSO, 1956-2003. Amsterdam : Boom, 2003.
Klep C. Peacekeepers in a Warlike Situation: The Dutch Experience // Erwin A. Schmidt. Peace Operations between Peace and War: Four Studies. Nummer 11 (September, 1998). P. 59-69. URL: http://www.bmlv.gv.at/pdf_pool/publikationen/01_11pop_05_klep.pdf, free.
van de Vijver J.G., van denBerghH.J. Unifil: Nederland en VN-vredesmachten. 's-Gravenhage, 1980.
Wiebes C. Intelligence and the war in Bosnia 1992-1995: The role of the intelligence and security services. Amsterdam, 2003.
Deployment of the armed forces interaction between national and international decision-making. Advisory Letter No. 56. The Hague: The Advisory Council on International Affairs, 2007.
Verloren onschuld: Nederland en VN-operaties / Adviesraad Vrede en Veiligheid. Den Haag : Adviesraad Vrede en Veiligheid, 1996.
Crisis management operations in fragile states. The need for a coherent approach. Advisory Letter No. 64. The Hague: The Advisory Council on International Affairs, 2009.
Military cooperation in Europe: possibilities and limitations. Advisory Letter No. 31. The Hague : The Advisory Council on International Affairs, 2003.
Transitional justice: justice and peace in situations of transition. Advisory Letter No. 65, AIV/No. 19. The Hague : The Advisory Council on International Affairs, 2009.
Honig J. W, Both N. Srebrenica: Record of a War Crime. N.Y., 1997.
Westerman F., Rijs B. Srebrenica, het zwartste scenario. Amsterdam, 1997.
NL Arms. Netherlands Annual Review of Military Studies 1997. The Bosnian Experience. Breda, 1997.
van der Lijn J., Ros S. Contributor Profile: The Netherlands // Vienna International Peace Institute, 26 September 2012.
Lessen uit Srebrenica: Nederland en internationale vredesmissies / onder red. van Weerdenburg J. Utrecht : Prestige, 1998.
A UN Rapid Deployment Brigade: Strengthening the capacity for quick response / ed. Leurdijk D.A. The Hague. Ando bv, 1995.
The Netherlands - Canada 1995 Distinguished Lecture Series: Proceedings. The Hague: Netherlands - Canada Committee, 1995.
van der Lijn J. De toekomst van Bosnie-Herzegovina zit muurvast // Internationale Spectator. 2010. Jaargang 64 r. 11. P. 67-68.
Anglo-Dutch Peace Support Operations Seminar. Den Haag, 1996.
The Changing Security Agenda: The National Experience of Peace-keeping and the Lessons for NATO. Report seminar for experts in the field of peace-keeping. The Clingendael Institute, The Hague, The Netherlands. April 5 and 6, 1993.
van der Lijn J. If only There Were a Blueprint! Factors for Success and Failure of UN Peace-Building Operations. URL: http://www.clingendael.nl/sites/default/files/20090218_joup_lijn3.pdf, free.
Voorhoeve J.J.C. Peace, profits and principles: a study of Dutch foreign policy. The Hague, 1979.
Hooman K. Vredesmissies dienen Nederlands belang. URL: http://www.clingendael.nl/publication/vredesmissies-dienen-nederlandsbelang?lang=nl, free.
Srebrenica: «A Safe Area». Nederlands Instituute voor Oorlogsdocumentatie (Netherlands Institute of War Documentation). Amsterdam, 2002. URL: http://www.niod.knaw.nl/en/srebrenica-report/report, free.
Hellema D.A. Dutch Foreign Politics. The role of the Netherlands in World Politics. Dordrecht, 2009.
Andeweg R.B., Irwin G.A. Governance and Politics of the Netherlands. N.Y., 2002.
 Historiography of Dutch peacekeeping in national and foreign research | Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta – Tomsk State University Journal. 2015. № 398.

Historiography of Dutch peacekeeping in national and foreign research | Vestnik Tomskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta – Tomsk State University Journal. 2015. № 398.

Download full-text version
Counter downloads: 1039