Who was the father of pharaoh Siptah?
The article is devoted to the question of parentage of the last male Pharaoh of XIX dynasty Siptah and his relationship to the Ramesside dynasty. The author examines three of his predecessors - Merenptah, Sethos II and Amenmessu, each of whom is usually regarded in historiography as Siptah's father. According to the author, there are no facts proving that Sethos II was the father of Siptah. On the contrary, the text on the ostracon CGC 25515 from workmen' village in Deir el-Medina, which mention about construction of Sethos II' royal tomb in Valley of the Kings and his death in his 6th regnal year, designates his successor on the throne Siptah not as the king's son but by very strange epithet "other". The author thinks that this fact can point out the absence of direct parentage between Sethos II and Siptah. Besides the author came to conclusion that Amenmessu could not be the father of Siptah because of the lack of any evidence too. The one argument that is usually used to prove their direct parentage, is the naos from British museum that is lost now. However, his shows that Horus name reproduction contains the inscription which mention the Horus name of Siptah as -||e. It is usually translated as "appearing in (the city) Khemmis". As it is widely accepted, this epithet can supposedly prove the direct parentage between Siptah and Amenmessu because the last bore the epithet «one whom (the goddesses) Isis nursed in (the city) Khemmis». The mention of one and the same place-name in epithets of both the Pharaohs can supposedly point out the direct parentage between the above-mentioned kings. But the author could not be translated as "appearing in (the city) Khemmis", but only as "appearing as the king of Lower Egypt". That is why the epithet of Siptah has nothing to do this the one of Amenmessu, and there are no other arguments to prove their direct parentage. In author's opinion, only Merenptah could pretend to this role. This opinion can be proved by the fact of changing Siptah's throne name from "Ramses-Siptah" on "Merenptah-Siptah" at the beginning of his reign. As it is suggested by many scholars, the mother of Siptah was the Asiatic concubine, and he had no legal rights to ascend the throne. The Great Chancellor Bay, one of the main political figures of end of the XIX Dynasty, mentioned that the accession of Siptah was accompanied by some struggles, and Bay must establish the young king on the throne of his father. One can suggest that Siptah could change his name to prove his legitimacy by reference of the origin from Merenptah.
Keywords
Сети II,
Мернептах,
Сиптах,
Аменмессу,
XIX династия,
Siptah,
Merenptah,
Amenmessu,
Sethos II,
XIX dynastyAuthors
Safronov Alexander V. | Moscow State Regional University; Institute of Oriental Studies, Russian Academy of Sciences | safronov1477@yandex.ru |
Всего: 1
References
Gauthier H.M. Dictionnaire des noms geographiques contenus dans les textes hieroglyphiques. T. 4. Le Caire : Societe Royale de Geographie d'Egyp-te, 1927. 226 p
von Beckerath J. Handbuch der agyptischen Konigsnamen. Mainz am Rhein : Verlag Philipp von Zabern, 1999. Xx + 314 s
Yoyotte J. Un souvenir du «Pharaon» Taousert en Jordanie // Vetus Testamentum. 1962. Vol. 12 (4). P. 464-469
Schneider Th. Siptah und Beja. Neubeurteilung einer historischen Konstellation // Zeitschrift fur agyptische Sprache und Altertumskunde. 2003. Hf. 130. S. 134-146
Callender V.G. Queen Tausret and the End of Dynasty 19 // Studien zur altagyptischen Kultur. 2004. Bd. 32. S. 81-104
Caminos R.A. Two Stelae in the Kurnah temple of Sethos I / Agyptologische Studien. Hermann Grapow zum 70. Geburtstag gewidmet. Firchow O., Grapow H., Hrgs. Berlin : Akademie-Verlag, 1955. S. 17-29
Gomaa F. Die Besiedlung Agyptens wahrend des Mittleren Reiches. II. Unteragypten und die angrenzenden Gebiete. Wiesbaden : Dr. Ludwig Rei-chert Verlag, 1987. 398 s
Prisse d'Avennes E. Antiquites egyptiennes du Musee Britannique (British museum) // Revue archeologique. 1847. T. 3 (2). P. 693-723
Сафронов А.В. Сети II и Аменмессу: два брата - два фараона - два врага // Вестник Московского государственного областного университета. Серия: История и политические науки. 2007. № 1. C. 27-41
Перепелкин Ю.Я. Египет после солнцепоклоннического переворота // История Древнего Востока. Ч. 2 / под ред. Г.М. Бонгард-Левина. М. : Гл. ред. вост. лит., 1988. С. 528-572.
Peden A.J. A Note on the Accession Date of Merenptah // Göttinger Miszellen. 1994. Hf. 140. S. 69.
Kitchen K.A. Ramesside Inscriptions. Vol. 5. Oxford : B.H. Blackwell LTD, 1983. Xxxii + 672 p.
Černý J.M. Ostraca Hiératiques. Fasc. 1. Le Caire : Imprimerie de l’IFAO, 1930. 83 p.
Porter B., Moss R.L.B. Topographical bibliography of Ancient Egyptian hieroglyphic texts, reliefs, and paintings. IV. Lower and Middle Egypt (Delta and Cairo to Asyut). Oxford : At the Clarendon press, 1934. Xxvii + 283 p.
Brand P.J. The usurped cartouches of Merenptah at Karnakan Luxor // Causing His Name to Live. Studies in Egyptian Epigraphy and History in Memory of William J. Murnane. Brand P.J., Cooper L., eds. Leiden ; Boston : Brill, 2009. P. 29-48.
Vandier J. Ramsès-Siptah // Revue d'Égyptologie. 1971. Vol. 23. P. 165-191.
Brand P.J. The monuments of Seti I and their historical significance: epigraphic, art historical and historical analysis. Ph. D. Toronto : University of Toronto, 1998. Xxvi + 548 p.
Lesko L.H. A Little More Evidence for the End of the Nineteenth Dynasty // Journal of the American Research Center in Egypt. 1966. Vol. 5. P. 29-32.
Gardiner A.H. Only One King Siptah and Twosre Not His Wife // The Journal of Egyptian Archaeology. 1958. Vol. 44. P. 12-22.
Kitchen K.A. Pharaoh Triumphant. The Life and Times of Ramses II. Cairo : The American University in Cairo Press, 1997. X + 272 p.
Beckerath von J. Queen Twosre as Guardian of Siptah // The Journal of Egyptian Archaeology. 1962. Vol. 48. P. 70-74.
Gauthier H.M. Le livre des rois d’Égypte. Tome 3: De la XIXe a la XXIVe Dynastie. Le Caire : Imprimerie de l’IFAO, 1914. 448 p.
Drenkhahn R. Die Elephantine-Stele des Sethnacht und ihr historischer Hintergrund. Wiesbaden : Otto Harrasowitz, 1980. X + 85 s.
Dodson A. Poisoned Legacy. The Decline and Fall of the Nineteenth Egyptian Dynasty. Cairo ; New York : The American University in Cairo Press, 2010. Xxvi + 196 p.
Aldred C. The Parentage of King Siptah // The Journal of Egyptian Archaeology. 1963. Vol. 49. P. 41-48.
An X-Ray Atlas of the Royal Mummies / eds. by J.E. Harris, D.F. Wente. Chicago ; London : The University of Chicago Press, 1980. Xxviii + 399 p.
Сафронов А.В. «Безымянный» сановник конца XIX династии и новые титулы «великого начальника казны» Баи // Вестник древней истории. 2008. № 3. C. 110-129.