Sin and crime in the "Sentences" of Taio of Zaragoza: the content and the sources of the concepts
The purpose of the article is to define the terms describing sin in the "Sentences" of Taio, a bishop of Zaragoza in the second half of VII century. To achieve this goal I tried to find the sources of Taio's concepts and to analyze the ways of citing and interpreting them. I selected some Latin words with an interesting sense (peccatum, delictum, iniquitas, vitium) and tried to compare meanings of them. My main source was "Sentences", a treatise wrote by Taio, a very readable book in the early medieval Europe. The "Sentences" contain five books. In the first, the author talks about God and the angels, in the second - about those who dedicated themselves to the service of God. The third book deals with various types of sacraments, as well as examples of the main Christian virtues. The fourth book, on the contrary, is devoted to various kinds of sin, the fifth deals with crimes, trial and justice. I also used the texts those had an enormous influence upon Taio: I mean "Moralia" of Gregory the Great and "Sentences" of Isidore of Seville. Taio adopted the ideas of Gregory and Isidore concerning the sin and its kinds. My conclusions could make clearer the sense of Latin words. "Peccatum" is a common world to describe the sins. Taio tried to do a hierarchy of sins and crimes. He divides the sins into graves and lights, secrets and overts. Every unwept sin, every sin without repentance pull the other sin, more grave and horrible, and in the end it is a web of sins, but a poor sinner cannot recognize it. The other synonims of "peccatum" are terms "vitium", "delictum" and "iniquitas". We use to translate "vitium" as vice. It means in "Sentences" seven cardinal vices, as greed, lust, anger, envy, despondency, gluttony and arrogance. "Delictum" is quite similar to "peccatum", they are getting muddled just in Antiquity, but usually "delictum" is more light sin or it is only bad thought. In the end "iniquitas" is injustice. Taio's ideas are not original at all; he took it over "Moralia" and Isidore's "Sentences". His originality consists in using and combination of two main works. He took a form and structure from Isidore's treatise and filled it by Gregory's ideas and examples. However, his "Sentences", with their relatively small volume and distinct structure became the source by which the ideas of Gregory the Great, expressed in "Moralia", were widely spread both in the Visigothic Kingdom and generally in medieval Europe.
Keywords
Тайон Сарагосский,
Григорий Великий,
Исидор Севильский,
интерпретация юридических понятий,
peccatum,
delictum,
Taio of Zaragoza,
Gregory the Great,
Isidore of Seville,
interpretation of Roman law,
peccatum,
delictumAuthors
Marey Elena S. | National Research University Higher School of Economics | elena.fontis@gmail.com |
Всего: 1
References
Уколова В.И. Исидор Севильский как деятель культуры раннего Средневековья // Проблемы испанской истории. М., 1984.
Уколова В.И. Античное наследие и культура раннего Средневековья (конец V - середина VII в.). М., 1989.
Fontainе J. Isidore de Séville et la culture classique dans l’Espagne wisigothique. Paris, 1959.
Díaz y Díaz M.C. Introducción general por M.C. Díaz y Díaz // San Isidoro de Sevilla. Etimologias. Edición bilingue preparada por José Oroz Reta y Manuel-A. Marcos Casquero. Madrid : Biblioteca de autores cristianos, 1993. T. 1-2.
Henderson J. The Medieval World of Isidore of Seville. Truth from words. Cambridge, 2007.
Марей Е.С. Энциклопедист, богослов, юрист: Исидор Севильский и его представления о праве и правосудии. М., 2014.
Биркин М.Ю. Социальные функции епископской проповеди в Толедском королевстве в начале VII века (по данным сочинений Исидора Севильского) // Теология и политика. Власть, Церковь и текст в королевствах вестготов (V - нач. VIII в.). М., 2017. C. 143-162.
Codoner C. La sententia y las Sententiae de Isidoro de Sevilla // Wisigothica. After M.C. Diaz y Diaz / ed. by C. Codoner y P.Farmhouse Alberto. Firenze, 2014.
Palacios Martin A. Tajon de Zaragoza y la «Explicatio in Cantica canticorum» // Anuario de Estudios Filologicos. 3. 1980. P. 115-127.
Taio Caesaraugustianus Episcopus. Epistolae // Patrologiae Latinae cursus completus. T. 80. Coll. 723-728".
Orlandis Rovira J. Historia del reino visigodo espanol: los acontecimientos, las instituciones, la sociedad, los protagonistas. Madrid, 2003.
Miguel Franco R. Ecos del Epistolarium de Braulio de Zaragoza en la carta prefacio de Tajon de Zaragoza a Eugenio de Toledo (CPL 1267) en los Moralia de Job // Lemir. 14. 2010.
Garcia Moreno L.A. La prosopografia del reino visigodo de Toledo. Salamanca, 1974.
Epistolario de San Braulio // Introd., ed., trad. por L. Riesco Terrero. Sevilla, 1975.
Марей Е.С. Средневековый епископ и античная литература: роль цитат в письмах Браулиона Сарагосского // Аристей. Вестник классической филологии и античной истории. IX. 2014.
Прозоров В.Б. «Моралии на книгу Иова» // Этика. Энциклопедический словарь / под ред. Р.Г. Апресяна, А.А. Гусейнова. М. : Гардарики, 2001. С. 274-275.
Evans G.R. The Thought of Gregory the Great. Cambridge, 1988.
Continuatio Hispana // MGH: AA. T. 11: Chronica Minora. Berolini, 1894. Vol. 2. P. 323-369.
Garcia Villada Z. Fragmentos ineditos de Tajon //Revista de archivos, bibliotecas y museos. 1914. T. 30. P. 23-31.
Ауров О.В. Власть, Церковь и текст в Испании до 1000 года // Теология и политика. Власть, Церковь и текст в королевствах вестготов (V-начало VIII в.). М., 2017.
Gregorius I Magnus. Moralium Libri Sive Expositio In Librum Beati Job. Pars I // Patrologiae Latinae cursus completes / еd. J.-P. Migne. T. 75; Pars II. T. 76. Paris, 1835.
Isidorus Hispalensis. Sententiae // Cura et studio Pierre Cazier. Corpus Christianorum. Series latina CXI. Turnholti, 1997.
Gastaldelli F. Prospective sul peccato in San Gregorio Magno // Salesianum. Vol. 28. 1966. P. 65-94.
Isidoro de Sevilla. Diferencias / Introduccion, edicion critica, traduction y notas por C. Codoner Merino. Paris : Les Belles Lettres, 1992;
Isidori Hispalensis episcopi Liber Differentiarum II // cura et studio M.A. Andres Sanz. Corpus Christianorum. Series latina CXI A. Turnhout : Brepols, 2006.
Марей А.В. Язык права средневековой Испании. От Законов XII Таблиц до Семи Партид. М., 2008.
Gregorius I Magnus. Homiliarum In Ezechielem Prophetam Libri Duo // Patrologiae Latinae cursus completes / ed. J.-P. Migne. Paris, 1835. T. 76.
Марей Е.С. Грамматика и богословие в «Дифференциях» Исидора Севильского // Вестник РГГУ. Серия «Исторические науки. Всеобщая история». 2013. № 13. С. 66-78.
Уколова В.И. «Различия» Исидора Севильского: Слово как инструмент познания // Средние века. 2016. № 77 (3-4). С. 368-376.