Husserl and Frege: Trajectories of Comparative Studies
Comparative studies of Frege's and Husserl's legacy do not lose intensity during seven decades. The aim of the article is the comprehension of preconditions and the main directions of those issues. The author considers Frege's Review of Dr. E. Husserl's Philosophy of Arithmetic (1894) as the historical precedent which is a prerequisite for a comparative research of Husserl and Frege. The diversions between Frege and Husserl regarding the concept of number are significant for setting up boundaries of logicism. Nevertheless, the author argues the nourishing source of the comparative analysis of Frege's and Husserl's doctrines is not their contradictions but their resemblance. The scholars worked out the problem of clean thinking (reinen Denken), which derives its categories from its development. They both tried to overcome the subjectivism and psychologism, free the logical categories from the psychological content. They both understood thought as the objective, universal entity that is independent of carriers. The scholars had common ontological and epistemological stances. The fact of their mutual criticism arouses keen interest in this context. This criticism invoked the resonance in such directions of the comparative studies as (1) discussion of the problem of Frege's and Husserl's psychologism and anti-psychologism; (2) assessment of the influence of Frege's ideas on the origin of phenomenology; (3) the search for the roots of the separation between phenomenology and analytic philosophy. The author considers the understanding of “psychologism” and its subsequent reception by Willard, Hanna, Dammett, Kusch, Mohanty, and Centrone. After that the author outlines the points of comparing in the early logical and mathematical works by Frege and Husserl (the concepts of number, multitude, equivalency; singular terms; proper names; indexicals; substitutivity). Further, the author concerns the discussion by F0llesdal, Mohanty, Rosado Haddock, Ierna, Zuh, and Kunne regarding the question of whether Frege's criticism was crucial to form phenomenology or not. In conclusion, the author considers the searches of the origins of the “gap” between analytic and phenomenological philosophy. The latter was detected by Dammett, Parsons, Cobb-Stevens, Willard, Ruin, Ladov, and others in the logical and semantic pioneering of Frege and Husserl.
Keywords
psychologism,
concept,
ideal unities,
phenomenology,
analytic philosophyAuthors
| Medova Anastasia A. | Reshetnev Siberian State University of Science and Technology; Krasnoyarsk State Pedagogical University named after V.P. Astafiev | amedova@list.ru |
Всего: 1
References
Husserl E. Logische Untersuchungen. Band 1, Prolegomena zur reinen Logik. Halle : Niemeyer, 1900; Zweiter Teil: Untersuchungen zur Phanomenologie und Theorie der Erkenntnis. Halle : Niemeyer, 1901.
Frege G. Der Gedanke. Eine logische Untersuchung; Die Verneinung. Eine logische Unter-suchung // Beitrage zur Philosophie des deutschen Idealismus. 1918-1919. Vol. I.
Frege G. Logische Untersuchungen. Dritter Teil: Gedankengefuge // Beitrage zur Philosophie des deutschen Idealismus. 1923-1926. Vol. III.
Фреге Г. Основоположения арифметики : Логико-математические исследования о понятии числа / вступ. ст. и пер. В.А. Суровцева. Томск : Водолей, 2000.
Husserl E. Philosophie der Arithmetik: Logische und psychologische Untersuchungen. Nijhoff, Den Haag, 1970.
Frege G. Rezension von: E. Husserl, Philosophie der Arithmetik I' // Zeitschrift fur Philosophie und philosophische Kritik. 1894. Vol. 103.
Frege G. Review of Dr. E. HusserI's Philosophy of Arithmetic // Readings on Edmund Husserl's Logical Investigations / ed. By J. N. Mohanty. Netherlands : Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, 1977.
Frege G. Uber Begriff und Gegenstand // Vierteljahresschrift fur wissenschaftliche Philosophie. 1892. Vol. XVI.
Фреге Г. Логика и логическая семантика: Сборник трудов. М. : Аспект Пресс, 2000.
Natorp P. Uber objektive und subjektive Begrundung der Erkenntniss (Erster Aufsatz) // Philosophische Monatshefte. 1887. Vol. 23.
Husserl E. Logische Untersuchungen. Erster Band: Prolegomena zur reinen Logik. Nijhoff, Den Haag, 1975.
Ruin H. Seeing Meaning: Frege and Derrida on Ideality and the Limits of Husserlian Intuitionism. Husserl Stud, 2011. Vol. 27.
Husserl E. Logische Untersuchungen. Zweiter Band - I. Teil : Untersuchungen zur Phanomenologie und Theorie der Erkenntnis. Tubingen : Max Niemeyer Verlag, 1968.
Гуссерль Э. Собрание сочинений. Т. 3 (1). Логические исследования. Т. II (1). М. : Гнозис, Дом интеллектуальной книги, 2001.
Husserl E. AReplyto a Critic of my Refutation of Logical Psychologism // Readings on Edmund Husserl's Logical Investigations / ed. By J. N. Mohanty. Netherlands : Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, 1977.
Husserl E. Review of Der Streit der Psychologisten und Formalisten in der modernen Logik by Melchior Palagyi // Zeitschrift fur Psychologie und Physiologie der Sinnesorgane. 1903. Vol. 31.
Микиртумов И.Б. Основные идеи «Философии арифметики» Гуссерля и логицизм Фреге // Логико-философские штудии. 2013. Вып. 10.
Willard D. The Paradox of Logical Psychologism: HusserI's Way Out // Readings on Edmund Husserl's Logical Investigations / ed. By J. N. Mohanty. Netherlands : Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, 1977.
Hanna R. Logical Cognition: Husserl's Prolegomena and the Truth in Psychologism // Philosophy and Phenomenological Research. 1993. Vol. 53. № 2.
Dummett M. Origins of Analytical Philosophy. Harvard University Press, 1993.
Kusch M. The Criticism of Husserl's Arguments Against Psychologism in German Philosophy 1901-1920 // Mind, Meaning and Mathematics / ed. by Leila Haaparanta. The Synthesis Library, Dordrecht/Boston: Kluwer Academic Publishers, 1994.
Mohanty J.N. The Concept of ‘Psychologism' in Frege and Husserl // Logic, Truth and the Modalities. Synthese Library. Vol. 278. Dordrecht : Springer, 1999.
Centrone S. Aspekte des Psychologismus-Streits. Husserl und Frege uber Anzahlen und logische Gesetze // Versuche uber Husserl / ed. by S. Centrone. Hamburg : Meiner, 2013.
Mohanty J. N. Husserl's ‘Logic of Truth' // Mind, Meaning and Mathematics: Essays on the Philosophical Views of Husserl and Frege / ed. Leila Haaparanta. Springer Netherlands, 1994.
Ortiz Hill C., Rosado Haddock G. Husserl or Frege? Meaning, Objectivity and Mathematics. Chicago : Open Court, 2000.
Beyer C. Husserl and Frege on Sense // Essays on Husserl's Logic and Philosophy of Mathematics, 2017.
Centrone S. Logic and Philosophy of Mathematics in the Early Husserl. Synthese Library Vol. 345. Dordrecht : Springer, 2010.
Мирошниченко П.Н. Готтлоб Фреге и логико-философская мысль конца XIX - начала XX века. Запорожье : Просвита, 2003.
Haaparanta L. Analysis as the method of logical discovery: Some remarks on Frege and Husserl // Synthese. 2004. Vol. 77.
Черноскутов Ю.Ю. Ранний Фреге и ранний Гуссерль: логика содержаний // Логикофилософские штудии. 2016. Вып. 14.
Pivcevic E. Husserl versus Frege // Mind. New Series. 1967. Vol. 76. № 302.
F0llesdal D. Husserl und Frege: Ein Beitrag zur Beleuchtung der Entstehung der phanome-nologischen Philosophie. Oslo : Aschehoug, 1958.
Rosado Haddock G.E. Edmund Husserl's Philosophie der Logik und Mathematik im Lichte der gegenwartigen Logik und Grundlagenforschung. Bonn, 1973.
Mohanty J.N. Husserl and Frege. Bloomington, Ind. : University Press,1982.
Ierna C. Husserl's Psychology of Arithmetic // Bulletin d'Analyse Phenomenologique. 2012. Vol. 8. № 1.
Zuh D. Wogegen wandte sich Husserl 1891? Ein Beitrag zur neueren Rezeption des Verhalt-nisses von Husserl und Frege // Husserl Stud. 2012. Vol. 28.
Kunne W. Die Philosophische Logik Gottlob Freges. Frankfurt am Main : Klostermann, 2010.
Willard D. Integrity of the Mental Act: Husserlian Reflections on a Fregian Problem // Mind, Meaning and Mathematics: Essays on the Philosophical Views of Husserl and Frege / ed. Leila Haapa-ranta. Springer Netherlands, 1994.
F0llesdal D. Bolzano, Frege and Husserl on reference and object // Future Pasts: The Analytic Tradition in Twentieth-Century Philosophy / eds. Juliet Floyd & Sanford Shieh. Oxford University Press, 2001.
McIntyre R. Husserl and Frege // J. Philos. 1987. Vol. 84.
Solomon R. Sense and Essence: Frege and Husserl // Analytic Philosophy and Phenomenology. The Hague, 1976.
Tragesser R.S. Husserl and realism in Logic and Mathematics. Cambridge University Press, 1984.
Parsons Ch. Husserl and the Linguistic Turn // Future Pasts: The Analytic Tradition in Twentieth-Century Philosophy / eds. Juliet Floyd & Sanford Shieh. Oxford University Press, 2001.
Cobb-Stevens R. Husserl and Analytic Philosophy. Springer Netherlands, 1990.
Ладов А.В. Аналитическая философия и феноменология // Аналитическая философия : учеб. пособие / под ред. М.В. Лебедева, А.З. Черняка. М. : РУДН, 2004.
Beyer C. Russell's Principle Considered from Both a Neo-Fregean and a Husserlian Viewpoint // Acta Analytica. 1998. Vol. 20.
Philipse H. Husserl and the Origins of Analytical Philosophy // European Journal of Philosophy. June 2008 Vol. 2, № 2.
Rosado Haddock G. E. Husserl as Analytic Philosopher // Husserl and Analytic Philosophy / ed. E. Guillermo. Rosado Haddock. De Gruyter, 2016.
Beyer C. Noema and Reference // Reference, Rationality, and Phenomenology: Themes from Follesdal / ed. Michael Frauchinger. Frankfurt/M.: Ontos, 2012.
