«Total responsibility of the answer» is considered as the hermeneutic principleof M.M. Bakhtin's philosophy | Tomsk State University Journal of Philosophy, Sociology and Political Science. 2012. № 2 (18).

«Total responsibility of the answer» is considered as the hermeneutic principleof M.M. Bakhtin's philosophy

In this article somesubstantive provisions of hermeneutic contour of philosophy of M. Bakhtin are revealed and consideredusing the material of his early products. So the analysis of article of Bakhtin «Art and responsibility» allows to open problematics of the whole and integrity which is important for understanding of hishermeneutics. The mechanical connection of different parts in one whole is opposed to internal unityof sense. From a problematics of the whole the problematics of unity which is found only in the personis born. A condition and the guarantor of unity is the unity of responsibility: «That I have worried andhave understood in art, I should answer with the life that all endured and understood doesn't remaininactive in it». On the model of mutual relations of «art» and «life» Bakhtin designates the principleswhich are of great importance for understanding his hermeneutic ideas.The understanding is connectedwith an ideological complex «I should answer with all my life» and also with effectiveness in the senseof detection in activity. The analysis of this complex reveals: the structure of the person, a problematicof obligation, the idea of the answer (before Another), and at last the total character of the answer(both for myself, and for another the person). Without this total responsibility of the answer it is impossible to say that something is understood. Guilt is connected with responsibility as the death isconnected with life. The guilt is a responsibility in the modus of death of the person. Therefore we cantell about the value of the mortal person and the value of death of the person for a hermeneutics. Thus,total responsibility of the answer is an understanding condition: «I should answer with the life» + «Ishould answer with the death».Esthetic vision opens one more modus of the person - the person as «ahero». The hero of his own product. In wider context (the early treatise to «Philosophy of the action») - he is the hero of life. «Hero» can be «bad» or «good», in any way it doesn't change his placein life - to be the valuable center. «Hero» appears as grace for us. Value of the person is to be grace.And this grace doesn't mean deleting the borders between «good» and «harm». This grace doesn'trecognize anything in the quality of «the last word», or «point». Grace is not to reconcile everything,but to manage to accept everything. And exactly because of it grace has got a hermeneutic value.

Download file
Counter downloads: 239

Keywords

«я» и «другой», человек, ответственность, вина, милость, «I» and «Another», the person, responsibility, guilt, grace

Authors

NameOrganizationE-mail
Krivosheev A. V.National Research Tomsk State Universityakriv@rambler.ru
Всего: 1

References

Беседы В.Д. Дувакина с М.М. Бахтиным. М.: Издательская группа «Прогресс», 1996. 342 с.
Исупов К.Г. Уроки М. М. Бахтина // М.М. Бахтин: pro et contra. Личность и творчество М.М. Бахтина в оценке русской и мировой гуманитарной мысли. Том 1 / Сост., вступ. ст. и коммент. К.Г. Исупова. СПб.: РХГИ, 2001. С. 7-44.
Бахтин М.М. Искусство и ответственность // Работы 20-х годов. Киев: Next, 1994. С. 5-9.
Бахтин М.М. К философии поступка // Работы 20-х годов. Киев, 1994. С. 9-69.
 «Total responsibility of the answer» is considered as the hermeneutic principleof M.M. Bakhtin's philosophy | Tomsk State University Journal of Philosophy, Sociology and Political Science. 2012. № 2 (18).

«Total responsibility of the answer» is considered as the hermeneutic principleof M.M. Bakhtin's philosophy | Tomsk State University Journal of Philosophy, Sociology and Political Science. 2012. № 2 (18).

Download file