Transnational indigenous structures, liberal multiculturalism, and narratives of indigenous separatism in Russia's North
This paper analyses narratives about nationalist sentiments and alleged separatist intentions of the Sami in the Kola Peninsula. Discussions about Sami ambitions to have their own state together with the Sami from Fennoscandia circulate in certain, predominantly urban, Russian social circles. Sami people are eager to distance themselves from such discussions and to reject any accusations on nationalist ground. My analysis reveals that the real fear that such narratives are indicative of comes not from any real possibility for independent Sami state or even Sami separatists intentions, but from possible spread of ideals inspired from (neo)liberal multicultural ideas, penetrating from abroad. In contrast to the previous liberal doctrines, neoliberal multiculturalism as an ideology accommodates the granting of collective rights as a compensation for past injustice to disadvantaged and more vulnerable parts of the population. The ideas behind neoliberal multiculturalism oppose the spirit of the Kola community. So, when imported from abroad, as an ideological subset of Sami cultural and ethnic revival support, they are accepted with suspicion and hostility. People intuitively feel threat- ened by such ideas, even though they may not have explicit knowledge of multiculturalism, which is not a part of the local discursive sphere.
Keywords
Murmansk Region,
liberalism,
multiculturalism,
international movement for indigenous rights,
Russian Sami,
Мурманская область,
либерализм,
муль-тикультурализм,
движение в защиту прав коренных народов,
саамыAuthors
Vladimirova Vladislava | Uppsala Centre for Russian and Eurasian Studies; Department of Cultural Anthropology and Ethnology; Uppsala University | vladislava.vladimirova@ucrs.uu.se |
Всего: 1
References
Кiselev А. “Saamskii zagovor” [The Sami Plot], Rasstreliannaia sem'ia (istoricheskie ocherki o kol'skikh saamakh) [The Executed Family (Historical Outlines About Kola Sami)]. Ed. by Stepanenko Aleksandr. Murmansk, 2002, pp. 189-196.
Walzer M. Comment // Multiculturalism and the "Politics of Recognition" / Ed. by Gutmann Amy. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1992. Р. 99-105.
Vladimirova V.K. Just Labor: Labor Ethic in a Post-Soviet Reindeer Herding Community. Acta Universitatis Upsaliensis Uppsala Studies in Cultural Anthropology, Uppsala: Uppsala Universitet, 2006.
Turner T. Anthropology and Multiculturalism: What Is Anthropology That Multiculturalists Should Be Mindful of It? // Cultural Anthropology. 1993. No. 8 (4). Р. 411-429.
The Social Life of the State in Subarctic Siberia. Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2003.
Thuen T. Quest for Equity: Norway and the Saami Challenge. Social and Economic Studies. Newfoundland, Canada: Institute of Social and Economic Research, 1995.
The Common Principles of Organization of Obshchiny of the Numerically Small People of the Far North, Siberia, and the Far East of the Russian Federation. 2000. No 30. 6 July.
Taylor Ch. The Politics of Recognition // Multiculturalism: Examining the politics of recognition. 1994. No. 25. Р. 25.
Ssorin-Chaikov N. V. Mothering Tradition: Gender and Governance among Siberian Evenki // Max Planck Institute for Social Anthropology Working Papers. 2002. No. 45.
Slezkine Yu. Arctic Mirrors. Russia and the Small Peoples of the North. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1994.
Rethinking Indigenous Politics in the Era of The "Indio Permitido " // Nacla Report on the Americas. Report on Race. Part 1. 2004. Р. 16-21.
Public Justice and the Anthropology of Law. Cambridge University Press, 2010.
Overland I.N. Politics and Culture among the Russian Sami: Leadership Representation and Legitimacy. University of Cambridge, 1999.
0verland I., Berg-Nordlie M. Bridging Divides: Ethno-Political Leadership among the Russian SaMi. New York: Berghahn Books, 2012.
Neoliberal Multiculturalism // PoLAR: political and legal anthropology review. 2005. No. 28 (1). Р. 10-19.
Niezen R. The Origins of Indigenism: Human Rights and the Politics of Identity. University of California Press, 2003.
Murmanskikh chinovnikov razdelil saami flag [The Flag Divided Murmansk Authorities and the Sami]. Club Regionov, 2013. Available at: http://www.club-rf.ru/51/news/29260 (Accessed 1 February 2015).
Modood T. Multiculturalism. John Wiley & Sons, 2013.
Muehlmann Sh. How Do Real Indians Fish? Neoliberal Multiculturalism and Contested Indi-geneities in the Colorado Delta // American Anthropologist. 2009. No. 111 (4). Р. 468479.
Luk'ianchenko T. Material'naia kul'tura saamov (loparei) Kol'skogo poluostrova v kontse XIX - XX vv. [Material Culture of the Kola Saami (Lopars) at the End of 19-20 Cc.]. Moscow: Nauka, 1971.
LENTA.RU. Прокуратура объявила саамов «иностранными агентами». 2013. URL: http://lenta.ru/news/2013/06/07/saam (дата обращения: 01.02.2015).
Kukathas Ch. Liberalism and Multiculturalism: The Politics of Indifference // Political theory. 1998. №>. 26 (5). P. 686-699.
Kublitz A. The Cartoon Controversy: Creating Muslims in a Danish Setting // Social Analysis, 2010. No. 54 (3). P. 107-125.
Kowal E. The Politics of the Gap: Indigenous Australians, Liberal Multiculturalism, and the End of the Self-Determination Era // American Anthropologist. 2008. No. 110 (3). P. 338-348.
Krupnik I. Reindeer Pastoralism in Modern Siberia: Research and Survival During the Time of Crash // Polar Research. 2000. No. 19 (1). P. 49-56.
Konstantinov Yu. Conversations with Power. Soviet and Postsoviet Developments in the Reindeer Husbandry Part of the Kola Peninsula. Acta Universitatis Upsaliensis. Uppsala: Uppsala University, 2015.
Kiselev A., Kiseleva T. Sovetskie saamy. Istoriia, ekonomika, kul'tura [Sovet Sami. History, Economy, Culture]. Murmansk: Murmanskoe knizhnoe izdatel’stvo, 1987.
King A.D. Living with Koryak Traditions. Playing with Culture in Siberia. Lincoln & London: University of Nebraska Press, 2011.
Josefsen E., Morkenstam U., Saglie J. Different Institutions within Similar States: The Norwegian and Swedish Samediggis // Ethnopolitics. 2015. No. 14 (1). P. 32-51.
Itogi Vserossiiskoi perepisi naseleniia 2010 goda v otnoshenii demograficheskikh i sotsial'noekonomicheskikh kharakteristik otdel'nykh natsional'nostei [Results of the All-Russian Census 2010], 2010.
Hall S. New Ethnicities // Stuart Hall: Critical dialogues in cultural studies. 1996. P. 441-449.
Golovnev A. V., Osherenko G. Siberian Survival: The Nenets and Their Story. Cornell University Press, 1999.
Hale Ch.R. Does Multiculturalism Menace? Governance, Cultural Rights and the Politics of Identity in Guatemala // Journal of Latin American Studies. 2002. No. 34 (03). P. 485524.
Geertz C. Distinguished Lecture: Anti Anti-Relativism // American anthropologist. 1984. No. 86 (2). P. 263-278.
Golovnev A. V., Kan S. Indigenous Leadership in Northwestern Siberia: Traditional Patterns and Their Contemporary Manifestations // Arctic anthropology. 1997. P. 149-166.
Funk D. In Search of a "Roster of 26 Smaller Peoples of the North" of Russia // Vargyas G. (ed.) Passageways. From Hungarian Ethnography to European Ethnology and Sociocul-tural Anthropology. Budapest, 2009. P. 315-329.
Fryer P. Russia's Sami: The Search for Autonomy in the Kola Peninsula // First World, First Nations. Internal Colonialism and Indigenous Self-Determination in Northern Europe and Australia. Eds. Minnerup Gunter and Pia Solberg. Sussex Academic Press, 2011. P. 97107.
FINUGOR, Инфоцентр. Флешмоб «Саамский Флаг» пройдет в Мурманске. 2014. URL: http://www.finugor.ru (дата обращения: 01.02.2015).
FLASHNORD. У Здания Правительства Заполярья Срезали Флагштоки Ради Саамов. 2013. URL: http://flashnord.com/news/u-zdaniya-pravitelstva-zapolyarya-srezali-flagshtoki-radi-saamov (дата обращения: 01.02.2015).
Finnougoria. Историческая справка. URL: http://www.finnougoria.ru/community/folk/ section.php?SECTION_ID=362&ELEMENT_ID=2557 (дата обращения: 01.02.2015).
Eller J.D. Anti-Anti-Multiculturalism // American Anthropologist. 1997. No. 99 (2). P. 249256.
Dvoretskaia G. Uvezu tebia v gorod, stanovishche pokazhu [I Will Take You to the City and Show You Our Camp], Murmanskii vestnik, 2012.
Dutton D. Authenticity in Art // The Oxford Handbook of Aesthetics / Ed. by Jerrold Levinson. New York: Oxford University Press, 2003. P. 258-274.
Donahoe B., Habeck J.O., Halemba A., Santha I. Size and Place in the Construction of Indi-geneity in the Russian Federation // Current anthropology. 2008. No. 49 (6). P. 993-1020.
Cowlishaw G. Culture and the Absurd: The Means and Meanings of Aboriginal Identity in the Time of Cultural Revivalism // Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute. 2012. No. 18 (2). P. 397-417.
Donahoe B. The Law as a Source of Environmental Injustice in the Russian Federation // Environmental justice and sustainability in the former Soviet Union. 2009. P. 21.
Byrne W.G. Multiculturalism, Culture and Anthropology // Teaching Anthropology: Society for Anthropology in Community Colleges Notes. 1995. No. 3 (2). P. 9-14.
Bryzgalova А. V ch'ikh rukakh flag? Mezhdunarodnyi den' saamov: Bor'ba za liderstvo v Murmanskoi oblasti [Who Holds the Flag? The International Sami Day: Struggle for Leadership in Murmansk Region], Natsional'nyi aktsent, 2015, 13 March. Available at: http://nazaccent.ru/content/14740-v-chih-rukah-flag.html (Accessed 1 February 2015).
Brubaker R Ethnicity without Groups. Harvard University Press, 2004.
Bogdanov N.B. Saamam Saamskuiu stranu?! [Give the Sami State to the Sami!?], Lowozerskaia Pravda, 2003.
Bessire L. The Rise of Indigenous Hypermarginality // Current Anthropology. 2014. No. 55 (3). P. 276-295.
Baumann G. Contesting Culture: Discourses of Identity in Multi-Ethnic London. Vol. 100. Cambridge University Press, 1996.
Beach H. Introduction // Post-Soviet Transformations: Politics of Ethnicity and Resource Use in Russia. Eds. Hugh Beach, Dmitri Funk and Lennard Sillanpaa. Uppsala: Uppsala University Press, 2009. P. 9-21.
Austin J.L. How to Do Things with Words. Oxford University Press, 1975. Vol. 367.
Afanas'evaN. andLeifR. Program of Aid to the Russian Sami. Utsjoki,1993.
Akademik Tishkov nazval sozdanie agentstva po delam natsional'nostei pravil'nym shagom [Academician Tishkov Defined the Newly-Established Agency for Nationalities Affairs a Step in the Right Direction], Natsional'nyi aktsent, 2015. Available at: http://nazaccent.ru/content/15178-direktor-instituta-etnologii-i-antropologii-privetstvoval. html (Accessed 1 February 2015).
"We Are Reindeer People, We Come from Reindeer". Reindeer Herding in Representations of the Sami in Russia // Acta Borealia. 2011. No. 28 (1). P. 89-113.