Bureaucratic, Scholarly, and Vernacular Thesaurus of the Deportation of Armenians in 1949
The article analyzes the deportation of Armenians during the Soviet operation “Wave” in June 1949, which resulted in the exile of about 19,000 people from the Armenian SSR, Georgia, Azerbaijan, and the Black Sea coast to Siberia. The author sees this case as a phenomenon that does not fit existing classifications of Soviet repressive practices and explores how bureaucratic, scholarly, and vernacular languages shaped the perception and representation of this trauma. It is shown that the categories defining deportee “contingency” (“Dashnaks,” “legionnaires,” “repatriates,” etc.) had not only administrative but also ideological functions, while for the deportees these designations were often unclear or rejected. The article explores how such labels were transformed in personal narratives, oral histories, and family archives, and how commemorative practices developed around the deportation. Based on field materials-in-terviews and visual sources collected within the Armenia Total(itar)is project-the article traces gendered differences in memory narratives, attitudes toward the past, and practices of preservation. In the absence of an official memory policy, commemoration was typically initiated by the repressed and their descendants. Through analysis of how memory was preserved, narrated, and visually framed, the article shows how the memory of the 1949 deportation integrates into Armenia’s broader memorial landscape, alongside memories of the Armenian Genocide and the Great Patriotic War, borrowing their symbolic language and representational forms. It demonstrates how the deportation experience and its representations reflect not only individual and family strategies of coping with trauma but also political and cultural shifts in post-Soviet Armenian society. The author declares no conflict of interests.
Keywords
Armenian deportation,
commemorative practices,
contingency,
repressions,
vernacular memory,
family archiveAuthors
| Shagoyan Gayane A. | Institute ofArchaeology and Ethnography, Armenian Academy of Sciences | gayashag@yahoo.com |
Всего: 1
References
Ablazhey N.N. (2011) Deportatsiya armyan v Altayskiy kray v 1949 g. [Deportation of Armenians to the Altai Province in 1949]. In: Gumanitarnyye nauki v Sibiri [Humanities in Siberia], 1, pp. 47-53.
Abramyan E.A. (2005) Zabytyy legion. Neizvestnyye stranitsy soyedineniya spetsial'nogo naznacheniya «Bergmann» [Forgotten Legion. Unknown Pages of the Special Purpose Unit “Bergmann”]. Yerevan: Apollon.
Albrecht R. (2008) Crime/s Against Mankind, Humanity and Civilisation. 1st edition. Munchen: GRIN Verlag, 2007 (published in 2008).
Arzamaskin Yu.N. (2001) Zalozhniki Vtoroy mirovoy voyny: Repatriatsiya sovetskikh grazhdan v 1944-1953gg. [Hostages of World War II: Repatriation of Soviet Citizens in 1944-1953]. Moscow: Fokus.
Bugay N.F. (1995) L. Beriya -1. Stalinu: «Soglasno Vashemu ukazaniyu...» [Beria to I. Stalin: "According to your instructions..."]. Moscow: AIRO-XX.
Dadrian V. (2003) The History of the Armenian Genocide: Ethnic Conflictfrom the Balkans to Anatolia to the Caucasus. Berghahn Books.
GARF (Gosudarstvennyy arkhiv Rossiyskoy Federatsii [State Archives of the Russian Federation]), F. R-9479, Op.1, D. 476, L. 39. Spetskontingenty, deportatsii i spetsposeleniya za 1930-1959 [Special contingents, deportations and special settlements for 1930-1959].
Gevorgyan R. (2015) Genotsid armyan. Polnaya istoriya [The Armenian Genocide. A Complete History]. Moscow: Yauza-katalog.
Guchinova E.-B. (2016) Risovat' lager'. Yazyk travmy vpamyatiyaponskikh voyennoplennykh o SSSR [Drawing a Camp. The Language of Trauma in the Memory of Japanese Prisoners of War about the USSR]. Sapporo.
Guchinova E.-B. (2024) «Ukazdogo svoa Sibir'». Rasskazy kalmykov o ssylke. [“Everyone has their own Siberia”. Stories of the Kalmyks about exile]. Moscow: Bumba.
Harutyunyan R. (2015) «Im hamar ink’y lav mard er» [“For Me He Was a Good Man”]. In: Kharatyan G., Shagoyan G., Marutyan G., Abrahamiam L. (red.). Stalinyan brrnachnshumnery Hayastanum. patmut’yun, hishoghut’yun, arrorya [Stalinist Repressions in Armenia: History, Memory, Everyday Life]. Yerevan: Gitutyun, pp. 330342 (in Armenian).
Irvin-Erickson D. (2017) Raphael Lemkin and the Concept of Genocide. Penn-University of Pennsylvania Press, Philadelphia.
Keshanidi Kh. (2015) Vyseleniye grekov SSSR v 1949 g. [The Deportation of Greeks from the USSR in 1949]. Athens.
Kharatyan G. (2020) Vyseleniye armyan «navechno» 1949 goda. Analiz i arkhivnyye dokumenty (K 70-letiyu etnicheskoy deportatsii armyan) [The expulsion of Armenians "forever" in 1949. Analysis and archival documents (On the 70th anniversary of the ethnic deportation of Armenians)]. Yerevan: Izd. IAE.
Kisibekyan A. (2011) Husher [Memories]. Vol. 2, Yerevan: Araspel (in Armenian).
Lehmann M. (2015) Apricot Socialism: The National Past, the Soviet Project, and the Imagining of Community in Late Soviet Armenia, Slavic Review, 74, no. 1 (Spring), pp. 9-31.
Marut‘yan H. (2001) «Tan surb» erevuyt‘o. Akunk‘neri harc‘o ev merorya drsevorumnero [The Phenomenon of “Household Saints”: The Question of Origin and Current Manifestations]. In: Hayoc‘ srbern u srbavayrero [Armenian saints and sanctuaries]. Yerevan: Armeniya, pp. 337-346 (in Armenian).
Mkrtich Armen, Zhirayr Glents. Yerevan: 1967 (in Armenian).
Pamyatnik i prazdnik. Etnografiya dnya Pobedy [Monument and holiday. Ethnography of Victory Day], by ed.: M. Gabovich. St. Petersburg: Nestor-Istoriya, 2020.
Pobol' N.L., Polyan P.M. (2005) Stalinskiye deportatsii. 1928-1953 [Stalin's deportations. 1928-1953]. Moscow: MfD: Materik.
Pohl J.O. (1999) Ethnic Cleansing in the USSR, 1937-1949. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
Polyan P. (2001) Ne po svoyey vole... Istoriya i geografiya prinuditel'nykh migratsiy v SSSR [Not of their own free will... History and geography of forced migrations in the USSR]. Moscow: O.G.I.
Rothberg M. (2009) Multidirectional Memory. Remembering the Holocaust in the Age of Decolonization. Stanford University Press.
Rumbaut R.G. (1991) The Agony of Exile: A Study of the Migration and Adaptation of Indochinese Refugee Adults and Children. In: Refugee Children: Theory, Research, and Practice. Eds.: Frederick L. Ahearn, Jr. and Jean Athey, Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press, pp. 53-91.
Shagoyan G. (2022) «Natsional'noye po soderzhaniyu i sotsialisticheskoye po forme»: palimpsest memorialov sovetskoy Armenii [“National in content and socialist in form”: a palimpsest of memorials to Soviet Armenia], Armyanskiy gumanitarnyy vestnik, 9, pp. 122-144.
Shagoyan G. (2022) Ch’matnelu hamar patzhvatsnery. Khmbagri koghmits’ [Those punished for not betraying. By the editor]. In: Tigran Sargsyan, Ch ’matnogh kanayk’ [Women who do not betray]. Yerevan: lAE press, Heinrich Boll Foundation, pp. 11-36 (in Armenian).
Shagoyan G.A. (2021) Kul'turnaya vs. kollektivnaya travma: memorializatsiya sovetskikh repressiy v postsovetskoy armenii po modeli pamyati o genotside [Cultural vs. Collective Trauma: Memorialization of Soviet Repressions in Post-Soviet Armenia Based on the Genocide Memory Model], Sibirskiye istoricheskiye issledovaniya - Siberian Historical Research, 2, pp. 73-98.
Tonoyan P. (2008) A Mi kyanq [Life]. Yerevan (in Armenian).
Zemskov V.N. (2016) Vozvrashcheniye sovetskikh peremeshchennykh lits v SSSR. 1944-1952 [The Return of Soviet Displaced Persons to the USSR. 1944-1952]. Moscow-St. Petersburg: Institut rossiyskoy istorii RAN; Tsentr gumanitarnykh initsiativ [Institute of Russian History, Russian Academy of Sciences; Center for Humanitarian Initiatives].
Zemskov V.N. (2018) Stalinskaya epokha. Ekonomika, repressii, industrializatsiya. 1924-1954 [The Stalin Era. Economy, Repressions, Industrialization. 1924-1954]. Moscow: Veche.